The Lyon Danse Biennale

Dance, Drink, Whatever…

Hofesh Shechter Company. Photo by Tom Medwell. Talk about tripping the light fantastic!

By Victoria Looseleaf

This gastronomic paradise – home to Paul Bocuse and potatoes Lyonnaise – also boasts one of the world’s epic dance festivals. Founded in 1984 by Guy Darmet, this 14th edition, which ran from September 9 to October 3 and was aptly called Encore! because it did deliver – more: With 740 artists coming from 17 countries to participate in 34 venues in and around Lyon, the festival offered 17 world premieres, as well as fistfuls of European and French premieres, and its always spectacular Defile (parade), where some 4500 fabulously garbed participants pranced down the enchanted central streets of Lyon.

The greatness commenced for me with Israeli-born Hofesh Shechter’s brilliant, 70-minute Political Mother. New to France, the work required the audience to wear earplugs, as the live, head-banging, metal-shrieking music, filled the house like so many amped-up molecules crashing around the universe. The militaryesque score proved the perfect soundscape to the tableaux of war, anger and rage-at-the-machine notions that continuously dissolved into smoky light, only to then be illuminated by harsh kliegs. Prisoners frolicked as monkeys, folk dancing bits sparkled like fireflies and drummers kept up their percussive blows. Assaulting with the force of a nuclear blast, one couldn’t look away, as the 10 dancers, between nihilistic flights of fancy, alternately took us to a place of love, hope and idealism, their hands saluting skyward, their bodies leaping in unfettered unison.

One can generally count on Maguy Marin for great theatricality. In the case of her world premiere, Salves (Bursts), a bit of ribald pie-throwing was thrown in for messy measure. Other vignettes featured schlepping planks of wood around (coffins?), the breaking of dishes, and dancers in black face and trench coats running amok. At one point, dry ice enveloped the area as chandeliers tinkled from above. Indeed, a haunted house mood crept in, after which we were awash in the sounds of rain – and even a Marx Brothers riff. With Marin taking her cues from philosopher Walter Benjamin, who once said, ‘Pessimism must be organized,’ sirens, tape hissing and a patina of chaos reigned. From this, Marin seemed to say, are moments that outlive oblivion, allowing her seven marvelous dancers to finally rise.

Another festival highlight: Tanztheater Wuppertal, founded by Pina Bausch in 1973, performing Bausch’s classic Nelken (Carnations), from 1982. Since her untimely death last year at age 68, the company carries on. What really astonished was seeing some of Nelken’s original dancers – Lutz Forster, Jean-Laurent Sasportes and Dominique Mercy. (I’d seen this piece in L.A. in 1996, and also had the honor of interviewing Bausch, the chain-smoking, notoriously soft-spoken genius nonpareil.)

Compagnie Maguy Marin. Photo by Christian Ganet. Anyone for dancing on the tabletop?

Mercy along with Robert Sturm, now direct the company, and to revisit this work was a gift, a glorious gift. Nelken features 12,000 carnations carpeting the floor, with dancers in gowns and heels (including men), often carrying chairs as they forge across the field. The musical pastiche offers stuff from Schubert and Gershwin, to Satchmo, Sophie Tucker and Lehar. This is dance-theater at its apotheosis, with the 21 performers screaming, talking, clutching vegetables and speaking directly to the audience. Four brutish looking men with German Shepherds also stopped in to patrol the field of flowers.

Surreal? Definitely, with dancers moving their chairs, sitting down and standing up again, in unison, in counterpoint. This is absolutely hypnotic, as Bausch’s performers, committed and precise, hurled themselves into scenes of ongoing humiliations. An onion-chopping bit is not likely to be forgotten, nor will Bausch. One of the towering geniuses of 20th century dance, it pains to say, “Pina is dead,” but for now, at least, with Tanztheater Wuppertal, Vive Pina.

Germaine Acogny’s world premiere, Songook Yaakaar, proved a disappointment because of the dancing, or lack thereof. Instead, this 66-year old Franco-Senegalese beauty and self-proclaimed voodoo priestess, chose to insert pop politics and culture, as well as singing into her solo. Fred Koenig’s video also distracted, while Acogny could benefit from a director. She should stick to her gorgeous movement vocabulary (not for nothing does she have a wonderful dance school in Dakar). The audience, on the other hand, rose as one to shake their hips, clap their hands and groove with Acogny at the show’s end, which then had more false endings than a Beethoven symphony.

Trisha Brown, hailed as the queen of postmodernism, is one of the founding members of the Judson School. Peeps across the pond (and in New York), can’t get enough of her. In Lyon, Trisha Brown Dance Company (looking positively ravishing), performed four works in a mini-retrospective. You Can See Us (1995), a duet once danced by Baryshnikov, was performed in silence but hardly felt radical. Her loose style, though, accenting natural movements, can be addictive. But less is more and both Foray Foret, from 1991 and Opal Loop Cloud Installation (a French premiere), from 1980, seemed like variations on the same theme, with the former making use of dry ice, the latter an offstage brass band. While Brown herself does not seem to be aging well at nearly 74, her latest work, L’Amour au theatre (2009), revealed complex moves that were smooth as Hermes silk, while slyly winking at Rameau’s early Baroque opera, Hippolyte et Aricie, heard on tape.

Two-time Tony award-winning choreographer Bill T. Jones, said he was concerned the French wouldn’t “get” his latest work, Fondly We Hope…Fervently Do We Pray (a premiere in France), performed by Bill T. Jones/Arnie Zane Dance Company. He was wrong, as the response was overwhelmingly positive, this reviewer’s included.

Dealing with the legacy of Abraham Lincoln (the title comes from Lincoln’s second inaugural address), the 80-minute dance-theater work is part history lesson, part screed and all terpsichorean beauty. Accompanied by powerful music, performed live, the piece begins with an exquisite solo for Shayla-Vie Jenkins to The Song of Solomon. We also see other characters and situations: Mary Todd, a former soldier born in 1975, and a slave auction. Personal histories are recited, including Lincoln’s and what could also be Jones’s. (“He is surprised that he never stops believing in great men, though he keeps it to himself.”)

The notion of liberty is probed, as well as scenes seemed ripped from today’s headlines – current issues like immigration and gay rights. What one is left with, finally, are ideas to ponder, but mostly, the memory of astonishingly, heartbreakingly luscious dance.

On the head-scratching side: Tania Oak Tree’s duet, Falling Eyes, a world premiere created by Portuguese choreographer Tania Carvalho (she also performed), that displayed robot moves. All eyes were, however, trained on Carvalho’s partner, Luis Guerra, who was sporting a sensuous unitard and Louise Brooks wig. With feet rooted to the ground, Guerra’s long windmill arms whooshed around aimlessly, until he began doing neo-push ups and strangely contorted things with his, yes, spectacularly muscled body. Also sub-par: Compania Angeles Gabaldon’s French premiere Del Quivir, a reference to a river. And there was water aplenty onstage when we longed, instead, for real Flamenco dance, not merely shawl swirlings, train flouncings and rolling on the floor. Oy! There was also a nod to Arabic music, but where was the snake charmer? Gabaldon went through more costume changes than Lady Gaga (one looked like a souk, another a brightly colored beach umbrella). But I hadn’t traveled 6,000 miles to see a bizarre wardrobe, I came for the dance, which is what was sorely lacking here.

The youthful Alvin Ailey II, on the other hand, offered exuberance, technique and an astonishing grasp of the Ailey legacy in two programs that included the beloved finale, Revelations, which is now 50, count’em, 50 years old.

The Defile. Photo by Stephane Rambaud. Street moves at their best!

I love Lyon and j’aime Guy Darmet for making this festival important, relevant and eternally fascinating. It may be his last as artistic director, but the Darmet spirit is one that should – and hopefully – will never die.

Posted in ALVIN AILEY II, BILL T. JONES, FRANCE, GUY DARMET, HOFESH SHECHTER, LYON, MAGUY MARIN, PINA BAUSCH, TANTZTHEATER WUPPERTAL, TRISHA BROWN | Comments Off on The Lyon Danse Biennale

Champion of Dogs and Underdogs

Singer-songwriter-pianist-activist Nellie McKay, whose latest CD packs a melodious punch.

By Mary Lyn Maiscott

In a tease for Nellie McKay’s performance tomorrow at the Greene Space, for WNYC’s “Soundcheck,” someone called her new CD, Home Sweet Mobile Home, “whimsical.” Perhaps, I thought—in a Weill-Brechtian way. The shark has pearly teeth, and also, with her sweet, slightly askew smile, does Nellie, who is sharklike only when she’s fighting the good fight, on behalf of animals (“Eatin’ that burger… Eatin’ that torture”), the disenfranchised (“So you’ll find me/Here right beneath the underdog”), and the never-franchised (“Please sir let me lay in the sewer that claimed me”).

Since Nellie played Polly Peachum in a 2006 Broadway production of The Threepenny Opera, the Weill-Brecht influence would not be surprising, but, aside from last year’s Doris Day tribute album, which involved singing (beautifully) about cockeyed optimism and sentimental journeys, Nellie has from the beginning—after all, her first CD was called Get Away from Me—given us clever, sometimes acerbic, always enlightened songs couched in a Tin Pan Alley musical sensibility. (For my interview with Nellie on the Doris Day album, go to Vanity Fair’s website.)

I had assumed the CD title’s mobile-home reference had to do with today’s economy—and it might—but Nellie told an interviewer that her “nana” lived in a trailer and she used to like visiting there, and the cover shows a faux-naïf painting (her own) of a happy, lipsticked cat putting on Nellie’s record in a cozy, rosy setting. The inside packaging contains more animal art, along with photos of a smiling, saronged Nellie (the album includes the lilting “Caribbean Time,” recorded in Jamaica), but in the background are drawings of smokestacks spewing pollution—yet, indeed, rather whimsically!

Such is the despairing/rejoicing world of Nellie McKay, which I hope you will enter if you have not already. My favorite song on the CD is “Bruise on the Sky,” with its poignancy, lovely and inventive harmonies, and typically startling lyrics (“I need your loving eyes/At least your cyanide”).

Nellie will be on “Soundcheck” October 12, and you can check out tour dates and download “Caribbean Time” at her website.

Posted in Home Sweet Mobile Home, Nellie McKay, Soundcheck | Comments Off on Champion of Dogs and Underdogs

Leaving Reason?

What they did for love: Kristin Scott Thomas 
and Sergi López.

Leaving (Partir)
Directed by Catherine Corsini
Written by Catherine Corsini with Gaëlle Macé
Starring Kristin Scott Thomas, Sergi López, and Ivan Attal

By Mary Lyn Maiscott

We first discovered Kristin Scott Thomas in the African desert, wowing Ralph Fiennes with her Katharine Hepburn–esque trousers and, later, her elegant clavicle. (Small-breasted women everywhere felt a moment of triumph as she glided sinuously from bed to tub.) Their illicit affair was at the heart of the somewhat soapy The English Patient, which provided that breakout role for Scott Thomas. Fourteen years later, we find her, as Suzanne in Leaving (Partir), in the lush South of France, married to a doctor and living with him and their teenage children in a sleek, well-appointed house. Suzanne is The Woman Who Has Everything—except, of course, passionate love, and so she is about to tumble for a penniless Spanish workman. He, Ivan (Sergi López), has come to help build her new reflexology office on the estate; their first meeting occurs when he spies her caressing her own foot while intoning other parts of the body.

As with just about every movie in which a married woman gets involved with another man, tragedy ensues (this isn’t a spoiler—the opening scene makes it clear, with the film then going back in time). But first there is plenty of very erotic love-making, tempered (a little) by the penury the new couple find themselves enduring—in that sense perhaps it’s a movie for our times—brought on by the rage and influence of Suzanne’s husband (Ivan Attal, who dubbed Tom Cruise’s voice for the French version of another troubled-marriage movie, Eyes Wide Shut).

Their efforts to keep afloat—does this well-established woman have no friends or family who could lend her a little money?—finally reach a point that you may or may not be able to accept. My fellow blogger Adam Nadler used the word “ridiculous” to describe it, while “unhinged” popped into my mind in regard to Suzanne. Perhaps this was intended, but since her actions strain credulity, even the remarkable Scott Thomas, who was nominated for a César Award for meilleure actrice for the role, cannot fully get back the pathos the story warrants. Still, watch her expressive, wide-eyed face—reminiscent of Diane Lane’s in the similar Unfaithful, itself based on the late Claude Chabrol’s film La Femme Infidèle—and fall in love again, consequence-free.

Posted in Catherine Corsini, Ivan Attal, Kristin Scott Thomas, Leaving, Partir, Sergi López | Comments Off on Leaving Reason?

Pining for Chris

Pistol-packing Pine. Photo by Craig Schwartz.


By Victoria Looseleaf

Who doesn’t love Chris Pine? Of course, I’ve only known him as a stage thespian, never having seen him in last year’s mega-hit, Star Trek, in which the movie star assayed the role of Capt. Kirk. (Brilliantly, so I heard. Maybe I’ll check out the flick on my next trip to France…).

In any case, Pine is one busy dude these days, starring in Martin McDonagh’s black farce, The Lieutenant of Inishmore, running at the Mark Taper Forum in downtown Los Angeles through August 8. Before that I had the pleasure of watching him hone his stage chops in Neil Labute’s dark comedy, Fat Pig (I was the program annotator at the Geffen Playhouse at the time – 2007), and then caught Pine’s sparring with Chris Noth, also at the Geffen, in Farragut North last year. Before his newest flick, Unstoppable, opens in November with Denzel Washington, here are three Spotlight on the Arts for KUSC-FM radio, the nation’s highest rated classical station in the country. Note the killer music by Bernard Herrmann (Psycho and Vertigo).

Violence Cubed
Two-Hour Blood Fest
Walk-Outs Galore

Posted in BERNARD HERRMANN, CHRIS NOTH, MARTIN MCDONAGH, NEIL LABUTE, PSYCHO, STAR TREK, VERTIGO | Comments Off on Pining for Chris

Memories of My Friend, Harvey Pekar


By Victoria Looseleaf

The city of Cleveland is mourning. Not because LeBron James decamped for Miami but because the much-maligned town has lost one of its true originals. Harvey Pekar, the surly comic book writer who began chronicling his hum-drum life in 1976 with the publication of American Splendor died early on July 12 at age 70.

Since I too grew up on those sometimes harsh streets of Cleveland, I reached out to Harvey on a visit home in the early 1980’s after becoming a Splendor fan. His number was listed, I called and, bringing bagels and cream cheese, I arrived at his cluttered Cleveland Heights apartment to talk about, well, life. For him that was toiling for years as a file clerk at the Veterans Affairs hospital, jazz, Cleveland’s lousy winters and just getting by.

Thus began our friendship, if it’s possible to be friends with someone suffering from anhedonia, the inability to experience joy. But I loved Harvey’s unjoie de vivre, and a few years after starting my Public Access show, The Looseleaf Report, in 1987, Harvey made the first of numerous appearances. Splendor had been adapted for the small stage, with Dan Castellaneta (voice of Homer Simpson) playing Harvey and Siobhan Fallon assaying Harvey’s wife. Did he like it?

Bah!

But I continued to champion him, even taping segments for the show in Cleveland, with Harvey, an old Jewish mensch named Emile, and genuine nerd, Toby Radloff. We riffed about donuts, work, Jewish holidays, whatever. One story concerned the time that Harvey, bearing bagels, came to see me at my grandmother’s (he loved old people), only to leave and discover his car had been towed. How Pekaresque is that?

I also happened to be in New York in 1987 when the curmudgeonly scribe was almost booted off Letterman’s show because he wanted to talk about NBC’s parent company, General Electric. But Dave would have none of it. Harvey then blurts out, “You’re full of shit, Dave,” and boom, they cut to commercial. Harvey, of course, turned the episode into a comic book – and much as I harped on him – I didn’t make it into Pekar’s pages.

Then there was Splendor, the movie. In Cleveland again, I forayed down to a funky bakery on a snowy November day to watch the shoot. There was Harvey, kvetching that it was for HBO and nobody would ever see it.

Yeah, well, you can’t keep a good anhedonic down. When I interviewed him for the L.A. Times for the movie’s opening in 2003, I asked him about possible Oscar attention.

“Oscars?” he replied. “All I see is bleakness.”

And this muttered from a suite at the Bel Age Hotel!

I know you had health issues, Harvey–cancer, high blood pressure, asthma, and that bugaboo, depression. But you also gave countless people happiness–and hope. I’m gonna miss you, friend, not only your formidable talents, but because you’re part of what makes Cleveland special.

 

I’m also grateful for your comics and books…almost as much as the Harvey bobble-head doll I got at that fabulous red-carpet premiere. Talk about splendor!

Posted in CLEVELAND, DAVID LETTERMAN, HARVEY PEKAR, LEBRON JAMES, Los Angeles Times, The Looseleaf Report | Comments Off on Memories of My Friend, Harvey Pekar

A Latter-Day Doris Day?

Singer Nellie McKay, deceptively light as air, is appearing at Feinstein’s at Loews Regency.

By Mary Lyn Maiscott

I hesitate to use the image for someone who I’m guessing is a pacifist, but Nellie McKay reminds me of a stealth bomber. With her creamy skin, blonde curls, silky voice, and sweet manner, she seems a throwback to … well, Doris Day, to whom she pays tribute in her current show at Feinstein’s at Loews Regency (and also in her CD Normal As Blueberry Pie). Yet McKay has a steely resolve when it comes to such issues as animal rights, the disenfranchised, gentrification, and her own musical integrity. (After a falling-out with Columbia Records, she is on the jazz label Verve.)

At the early show Saturday night, her politics were not much in evidence (she did mention Doris Day’s own animal activism) but her absurdist humor was—she introduced a couple of members of her excellent band (Jay Berliner on guitar, Ben Bynum on drums, Kenny Davis on bass, Glenn Drewes on trumpet, Belinda Whitney on violin) as “the Antichrist” and “the original Anna Karenina” (and that wasn’t Belinda). Wearing a retro black strapless gown with red lining, along with silver pumps with rhinestone bows, she began her set with “Sentimental Journey,” and in a sense that’s what she was taking us on. Along the way—with standards like “Close Your Eyes” and “Mean to Me”—there were overtones of big bands, the 1940s, swing, and Alice Faye, with special dedications to the late Kitty Carlisle Hart, who began playing Feinstein’s in her 90s, and Rue McClanahan, who died last Thursday.

And all of this was beautiful (especially in the swank environment of Feinstein’s)—with such instrumental touches as delicate xylophone on “The Very Thought of You” and violin doubling a vocal line on “Do Do Do.” Still, it was great to have the singer leave her piano and stroll to the center mic with her ukulele for a rendition of Lennon and McCartney’s “A World Without Love” and her own songs “Bodega” (“Adopt a bodega!” she urged), “Caribbean Time,” and “Mother of Pearl.” She introduced the last, on its surface an antifeminist diatribe, by saying, “This is from Miss Day’s little-known album Viva Vajayjay.” And ended it with, “I’m Sarah Palin and I approve this message.” (Hmm, maybe I’m a little wrong about the politics.)

There are perhaps not many performers who could blend the sensibilities of “The Dog Song” (“If you want a companion/Well just go right to the pound”) and “Black Hills of Dakota,” but by following her passions and her own musical style, the exuberant McKay has created a lovely, entertaining, beguiling, and even edifying show (pretty stealthy, Nellie).

“Normal As Blueberry Pie: A Tribute to Doris Day” continues through June 12 at Feinstein’s at Loews Regency in N.Y.C.

Posted in Doris Day, Feinstein’s, Nellie McKay, Normal As Blueberry Pie | Comments Off on A Latter-Day Doris Day?

Boy II Man

Ben (Michael Douglas) and ex-wife Nancy (Susan Sarandon) on the campus bench where they first met.

Solitary Man
Directed by Brian Koppelman and David Levien
Written by Brian Koppelman
Starring Michael Douglas, Susan Sarandon, Danny DeVito, Jenna Fischer, Jessie Eisenberg, Mary-Louise Parker, and Imogen Poots

By Mary Lyn Maiscott

Coming across as a potent combination of Rabbit at Rest and Wonder Boys, Solitary Man explores, among other things, the combustion that can occur when deteriorating, experienced middle age meets beautiful, inexperienced youth. “You can’t cheat death,” his ex-wife, Nancy, tells the 60ish Ben (played by Michael Douglas, appropriately craggy and sexy, who also starred in Wonder Boys). But once his doctor finds a worrisome heart abnormality, Ben does try, by cheating—spectacularly—in both his marriage and his business. A former Forbes cover boy, Ben loses it all by perpetrating a scam in his auto dealership empire (ironically, he’s touted himself as “New York’s honest car dealer”). He’s reduced to asking not only Nancy (the ever lovely Susan Sarandon)—with whom he’s on good terms, perhaps because she’s found her own success in real estate—for the occasional “loan,” but also their daughter (Jenna Fischer, here a homemaker out of The Office), whose lawyer husband is onto Ben’s manipulative tricks.

Ben thinks he’s found a solid way out of his financial predicament, however, and of course it takes the form of a woman: his girlfriend (on whom he also constantly runs around), played icily by Mary-Louise Parker, whose powerful father can get Ben restarted. But first, a favor: she asks Ben to accompany her 18-year-old daughter (Imogen Poots, in a role right out of Gossip Girl) to his alma mater and use his influence there on her behalf; after all, the library’s named after him, a reminder of radically better days. Once they’ve arrived, Ben’s cockiness—he engages in a dangerous conversation about sex with the girl and takes a nerdy sophomore (Jesse Eisenberg) under his broken wing—leads to events that cause his new foundation to crumble.

The movie’s title—it opens with Johnny Cash’s cover of the Neil Diamond song—could be a joke, given Ben’s epic womanizing. But this is a serious film that knows that this man—despite his supportive ex-wife, loving (though reaching her limits) daughter, adoring grandson, and loyal friend (Danny DeVito as a campus café owner)—is alone, because of his actions and, ultimately, because we all are. Looking at mortality, and one man’s understandable but impossible flight from it, in the way it does, Solitary Man could have been depressing. Instead, because it also uncovers the richness and complexity of life, it’s uplifting.

Posted in Danny DeVito, Imogen Poots, Jenna Fischer, Jessie Eisenberg, Mary-Louise Parker, Michael Douglas, Solitary Man, Susan Sarandon | Comments Off on Boy II Man

This Is Your Movie on Drugs

Becky (Hanna Hall) and Victor (Mark L. Young), the children of aging hippies, take drugs and have sex in a dystopian commune where everything is permissible.

Happiness Runs
Written and directed by Adam Sherman
Starring Mark L. Young, Hanna Hall, Jessie Plemons, Rutger Hauer, Andie MacDowell, Laura Peters, and Shiloh Fernandez

By Robert Rosen

I normally don’t write about movies I can’t stand, but I’m making an exception for the relentlessly downbeat Happiness Runs because it’s almost Reefer Madness–like in its depiction of hippies, communes, sex, drugs, and the impact that the ’60s had on the world we live in today. In a sense, Happiness Runs might be even worse than Reefer Madness. While the latter film was intended as nothing more than propaganda, and now seems absurd, writer-director Adam Sherman, who says he based Happiness Runs on his experiences growing up on a Vermont commune, intended his film as art, and he did succeed in making me care about his doomed characters. Which is why I warn you: If you have any good memories of the ’60s, this film, which seems overly long at 88 minutes, is a total bummer.

The movie, set in a rural commune that could be anywhere, appears to take place around 1987. But some of the characters are deep into snorting Oxycontin, and that didn’t come into vogue until 1997.

Though time and place are vague indeed, the filmmaker’s take on the aging hippies who founded this commune is crystal clear: They are insane, immoral, emotionally crippled, manipulative, and easily manipulated sex fiends who don’t give a shit what their children do. And their children, who begin smoking weed and drinking hard liquor daily around age 10, develop into super-promiscuous, self-mutilating, drug-dealing drug addicts and alcoholics who set cows on fire for entertainment and aspire to rip off drug stores for their Oxycontin supply.

In the climactic scene (and you can shoot me if you consider this a SPOILER), Becky, convincingly played by the gorgeous Hanna Hall, eats a bag of magic mushrooms and washes it down with a bottle of Jack Daniel’s after her father, who was suffering from terminal cancer, commits suicide. Wearing only a pair of panties, she climbs to the top of an abandoned Ferris wheel and jumps. The camera then lingers on her beautiful naked corpse—making me wonder if beautiful naked corpses have become a fashionable ploy in troubled independent films (see After.Life).

Writer-director Adam Sherman has said that making this movie was “like therapy,” and I’m sure it was. But because there was nothing therapeutic about watching it, I will ask one small favor of Mr. Sherman: In the future, man, don’t lay your bad trip on me.

Posted in Adam Sherman, Andie MacDowell, communes, Hanna Hall, Happiness Runs, hippies, Jessie Plemons, Laura Peters, Mark L. Young, Rutger Hauer, Shiloh Fernandez | Comments Off on This Is Your Movie on Drugs

A New York Estate of Mind

Walking and talking: Teenager Abby (Sarah Steele) and her mother, Kate (Catherine Keener).

Please Give
Written and directed by Nicole Holofcener
Starring Catherine Keener, Amanda Peet, Oliver Platt, Rebecca Hall, Ann Guilbert, and Sarah Steele

By Mary Lyn Maiscott

As I have a bit of a skin problem myself at the moment, I can sympathize with Abby (Sarah Steele), the 15-year-old character in Nicole Holofcener’s new film, Please Give. Abby is dealing not only with a mother melting down from liberal guilt, but, worse, with acne (“Oh, that’s bad,” says another character, who gives facials, “it looks cystic”)—which is both on her face and in ours. Can’t she cover it up a little? I couldn’t help wondering. But such is the way of Holofcener, whose movies (Walking and Talking, Lovely & Amazing, Friends with Money) are much more like real life than most of what you’ll see on the big screen. (Her one “lapse” may have been the use of the glamorous Jennifer Aniston in Friends with Money, except that Aniston fared much better in that movie and in Miguel Arteta’s The Good Girl than she has in more air-brushed, so to speak, films.) During Friends with Money, when Holofcener’s muse Catherine Keener, as half of a screenwriter couple, berates her husband for not properly sympathizing when she gets hurt, my own husband whispered to me, “Sounds like arguments we’ve had.” Indeed.

In the director’s new film, Keener plays Kate, a woman uncomfortable with her own upper-middle-class comfort, which is, oddly, enhanced by the dead and almost dead: She buys furniture from the estates of the newly deceased for her upscale antique store, and she and her husband, Alex (the “real”-looking Oliver Platt), have already bought the apartment next door from the elderly woman, Andra (Ann Guilbert, once a neighbor on The Dick Van Dyke Show), who lives in it; when she dies, they’ll be able to smash right through and have an even bigger place in their stately East Village building.

Andra’s granddaughters—Mary (Amanda Peet), who is almost unbelievably blunt (see acne remark above), and Rebecca (Rebecca Hall), the sweet to Mary’s sour, who does most of the caretaking for their grandmother (also sour)—only serve to exacerbate Kate’s guilt about Andra, sometimes intentionally, sometimes not. Yet they affect Kate’s family—Abby and Alex—in ways that Kate cannot. Somewhat distracted by her desire to make the world a better place, Kate tries to volunteer for work with both the very old and children with Down syndrome but finds herself overcome by their situations (in a reversal, one of the children attempts to help Kate when she ends up a blubbering heap in a restroom stall). Instead, Kate hands out money and leftovers indiscriminately to anyone who even appears to be homeless.

This is kind of Wallace Shawn Lite, yet Kate truly is struggling and she truly does love her family. (In an unusual and touching development, Abby and Alex indirectly share a secret they keep from Kate, demonstrating the sometimes delicate interweaving of family dynamics.)

Holofcener does not concern herself too much with plot. In her movies a person can have an affair without any eventual explosions or can suffer a depression that shows itself, rather than in hitting the bottle, in not hitting the shampoo. This can make her work seem more natural than contrived—a more leisurely and less intellectual Woody Allen, whom Holofcener once worked for.

In the character-driven Please Give, there is only one off note that I can perceive (well, apart from nearly every New Yorker going bonkers over getting to the country to watch the fall leaves “peak”): Those two young women never give a hint of being resentful at not inheriting their grandmother’s great apartment. Really?

Posted in Amanda Peet, Catherine Keener, Nicole Holofcener, Oliver Platt, Please Give, Rebecca Hall | Comments Off on A New York Estate of Mind

Exquisite Corpse

Anna Taylor (Christina Ricci) leaves a good-looking corpse.

After.Life
Written and directed by Agnieszka Wojtowicz-Vosloo
Starring Christina Ricci, Justin Long, Liam Neeson, and Chandler Canterbury

By Robert Rosen

I might just as well have called this review “Necrophiliac’s Delight,” because that’s what this queasy, creepy film is—a cinematic work designed to sexually excite those among us who are turned on by the idea of making love to a beautiful young corpse. And that exquisite corpse—or is it?—is played by Christina Ricci, who parades around a mortuary in the fetching red satin slip that she died in, though she also spends a great deal of time completely nude, and the camera does not shy away from lingering over her pert, dead nipples. So if your idea of a dream lover is a very pale Ms. Ricci laid out on an embalming slab, and you’re not put off by that rather unbecoming gash in her forehead, then After.Life is the movie of your dreams.

Let’s not even talk about the nonsensical plot, beyond saying that Ricci’s character, Anna Taylor, is killed in a car crash after a fight with her boyfriend Paul Conran (Justin Long)—who brings to mind David Schwimmer as Ross (minus the whining)—and her body is turned over to a sinister, Twilight Zone–style funeral director, Eliot Deacon (Liam Neeson), who possess the ability to talk to the dead (or does he?). There’s another Twilight Zone–ish touch, as well—the old dead-person-calling-on-the-telephone routine. Add a pinch of Roger Corman’s take on Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Fall of the House of Usher,” and I think you’ve got the picture.

All of which is not to say that After.Life is without merit. Writer-director Agnieszka Wojtowicz-Vosloo did a fine job creating the macabre funeral parlor atmosphere—this is definitely not the cozy family world of Six Feet Under—and the film did indeed creep the hell out of me, until it began to grow tedious. But in terms of plot and logic and sheer compellingness, it doesn’t come close to modern horror classics like The Others or The Sixth Sense, both of which I enjoyed without reservation. But I will say that if I’d seen this film when I was eight, as I was when I saw The House of Usher, I’d have had nightmares for at least the next year.

Posted in Agnieszka Wojtowicz-Vosloo, Christina Ricci, Justin Long, Liam Neeson, necrophilia | Comments Off on Exquisite Corpse